top of page
A running ranking of the year's best books


The Mayor of Maxwell Street
★★★★★ Skillful dialogue and prose adorn this debut that combines a love story with the search for a mysterious gangster in 1920s Chicago.

Greg Barlin
Dec 27, 20245 min read


The God of the Woods
★★★★★ Set in 1975, the search for a missing child acts as the foundation for Moore's tactful exploration of societal themes of the time.

Greg Barlin
Dec 23, 20243 min read


Listen for the Lie
★★★★★ A woman returns to the small town where she grew up, despite being the prime suspect in the 5-year-old murder of her best friend.

Greg Barlin
Dec 21, 20243 min read


The Year of the Locust
★★★★★ Another great spy thriller from Hayes after 10 long years. Despite some questionable supernatural plot choices, it's still a winner.

Greg Barlin
Dec 19, 20244 min read


Pony Confidential
★★★★★ Part mystery, part odyssey, the story follows a sardonic pony as he seeks to reunite with his human, on trial for a 25-year-old murder

Greg Barlin
Dec 18, 20244 min read


Wordhunter
★☆☆☆☆ A forensic linguistics student begins helping police solve crimes, while engaging in the most unrealistic dialogue I read all year.

Greg Barlin
Dec 17, 20243 min read


The Boyfriend
★★★★☆ A quick bubblegum thriller from the queen of the twist which will keep you guessing even when you know the misdirection is coming.

Greg Barlin
Dec 17, 20242 min read


We Solve Murders
★★★★☆ A new setting and cast of characters, but the same humor, heart, and layered mystery that readers have come to expect from Osman.

Greg Barlin
Dec 13, 20242 min read


Lenny Marks Gets Away With Murder
★★★★☆ Lenny Marks lives a carefully crafted and ordered life for herself until her stepfather's parole sparks memories of childhood trauma.

Greg Barlin
Nov 19, 20242 min read


The Last One at the Wedding
★★★☆☆ An unfortunately average mystery about a father and his growing concerns that his daughter's fiancé could have a dark and sordid past.

Greg Barlin
Nov 2, 20242 min read


The Top 50 Books of the Last 5 Years (2020-2024)
Inspired by an underwhelming list from Goodreads, this counts down a far superior list of the Top 50 books of the last 5 years (2020-2024).

Greg Barlin
Oct 16, 20248 min read


The Night We Lost Him
★★★★☆ When a man falls from the cliffs adjacent to his seaside home, his son and daughter collaborate to uncover the truth behind his death.

Greg Barlin
Oct 4, 20243 min read


The Return of Ellie Black
★★★★☆ A borderlined-5-star thriller that unveils what happened to Ellie Black, who went missing for more than two years but has now returned

Greg Barlin
Oct 3, 20243 min read


Assassins Anonymous
★★★★☆ A fresh take on the assassin genre, balancing globetrotting action with a main character truly trying to change via a 12-step program.

Greg Barlin
Sep 2, 20244 min read


Don't Let the Devil Ride
★★★☆☆ A slightly-better-than-average southern noir thriller about a wife's search for her missing husband, who might not be who she thought.

Greg Barlin
Aug 18, 20242 min read


Hunted
★★☆☆☆ A frustrating thriller, packed with unlikable characters and plot holes I could drive a truck through. Significantly disappointing.

Greg Barlin
Jul 15, 20243 min read


Devil's Kitchen
★★★★☆ Reminiscent of "The Shield", it's a split between a missing persons mystery and a dirty firefighting crew committing thefts in NYC.

Greg Barlin
Jun 22, 20243 min read


The River We Remember
★★★★☆ While a murder mystery is at the heart of this novel, a cast of flawed characters enable the exploration of several weighty topics.

Greg Barlin
May 5, 20243 min read


The Frozen River
★★★★☆ Inspired by historical events, a midwife in 1789 finds herself in the middle of both a murder and a rape investigation in her town.

Greg Barlin
Apr 5, 20244 min read


The Hunter
★★★★☆ French's sequel to The Searcher again slowly builds up the plot -- and the tension -- until a murder mystery dominates the second half

Greg Barlin
Mar 16, 20243 min read
Subscribe
bottom of page